If you go to the "Edit Profile" page here on italki, you see that there are areas for short and long introduction. So right off the bat, an introduction is just a small portion of the profile.
The second difference is that you introduce yourself but you don't profile yourself. An introduction contains basic info you want others to know about you, often in complete sentences. Profile goes much deeper, usually contains stats like sex, hair color, eye color, hobbies, likes and dislikes. You use a website like italki to introduce yourself, but the website keeps a profile of you to decide what ads to show, and other users read your profile to determine if you're a good candidate for a language partner.
So an introduction is just casual info while a profile serves a purpose. Websites don't ask for your info just for fun. They intent to do something with it. Hence it's a profile. If you say you profile someone on the web, I would immediately ask "why?"
I would say avoid using the word profile. It's not good when the government/the police profiles us, and it's not good when you profile somebody (pretty creepy).