Hi!
I am not a chinese teacher, just a student :-) But I just thought I would share some of my experiences with the tones..
Regarding the first tone: my impression is that the most important thing is that this tone does not change frequency as you say it. It is, if you exagerate, like singing <em>one</em> tone - without changing the pitch.. I dont think it matters that much if it is a Csharp or another tone, and I think that the actual tone chosen can also depend on the meaning of the sentence and what has been said before etc.
For example, I think the word zhende (really) is pronounced in a higher pitch if it is meant as a question, than if it is meant as an assertion. Also, my impression is that if two first tones are pronounced in a row, then usually the second one is pronounced with a somewhat lower pitch than the first one? (Any native speakers feel free to correct me..)
My point is I think you can choose the tone that feels natural to you and see how that works. The most important thing is how the tones are <em>relative to each other</em>, and not the actual tone. (That is my guess, anyways, but I am just a student as well.)