Search from various English teachers...
[Deleted]
DIE of DAT Vul in die of dat: Zal ik dit boek kopen voor Marga? Ja, dat is een leuk idee. _______ heeft ze nog niet, denk ik. The answer says DAT and DIE are both possible. To me, het boek => DAT. How can be that DIE is also possible here? My next question is, if a word is a het word, and I am referring to its plural form, shall I use DIE or DAT? (If I was referring to "de boeken" for example)

Answers · 4

0
It's a really good question. I've never even actively thought about it, but there's definitely a difference in meaning between 'die' en 'dat' in this context and it doesn't really have anything to do with gender of the thing referred to. 'Die' is used for a specific thing and 'dat' is used for a 'general' group/kind of things. In this context 'die' fits probably best. 'Die heeft ze nog niet.'='She doesn't have that one yet.' (she doesn't own the specific title so you can still use it as a gift). 'Dat' can also be used though in a slightly different context: 'Dat heeft ze nog niet.'='She doesn't have such a thing yet.' (it is a book about a certain subject, say fishing, and she doesn't have any books about fishing yet).
0
Hi I wanted to add that when the word reflects directly on the noun, the rules are pretty strict. So: het boek dat.... de boeken die... You cannot use them interchangeably. This is also in the case of referring to items like this: dit/dat boek, die/deze boeken (this/that book, these/those books). But when in English you would say "this/that/those/these one(s)", there is more flexibility. So following your example, all these things would be correct: Dat heeft ze nog niet (e.g. when somebody else holds the item) Dit heeft ze nog niet (e.g. when you hold the item) Die heeft ze nog niet (e.g. when somebody else holds the item) Deze heeft ze nog niet (e.g. when you hold the item) You would expect that the article and the plural matter for which one you should use, but that is not the case!
0
I am miss Rainna i like to have communication with you , So kindly keep in touch with me right here < [email protected] > to enable us to know better , I will send you my Detail . also i have special something to discuss with you, hope to see your mail soon.
0
When referring to 'de boeken' you will have to refer to it as DIE because it's a 'de' word in this form. Your first question is difficult to answer for me since I'm not a Dutch teacher. They would probably know how to answer this. I would personally in that specific sentence always use DIE. However when you have a sentence like this: Het boek, ____ ik gelezen heb. In this situation you away use DAT, like you would naturally do.

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today