Search from various English teachers...
Chile flagSebastian Lopez
It is possible to use "dream of" to talk about actual dreams? I've found this sentence in a book about dream interpretation written by an American psychologist ("Inner Work" by Robert Johnson): "The woman who dreams of this archetype (archetype of love) is not made up only of the urge to love. She also has the capacity for hatred or spite, as we all do, hidden away somewhere within her total personality" I am confused because I learned that "dream about"is the correct form to talk about actual dreams, and when refering to aspirations and goals you must use "dream of". Is that sentence an exception to the rule? I'm also confused about the meaning of the phrase"made up only of the urge to love". Isn't "made up" an expression to describe something false or asembled? What's the meaning of the phrase?

Answers · 3

1
On your first question, I have seen the two used interchangeably, although you are right that 'dream of' usually is followed by a verb (dream of becoming a doctor) and 'dream about' is usually followed by a noun (dream about goats). Please note, though, how 'I dream of becoming a doctor' and 'I dream about becoming a doctor' could both be used in a figurative manner as well as in a literal manner. In the passage you cite, it is not all that clear whether the author is using it in one way or the other. Although the subject matter of the book is dreams (suggesting the author's meaning is the literal one), he may be referring to the general idea of a woman who 'dreams of' an archetype as in she idealizes that archetype, namely the archetype of love. On your second question, 'made up' is not exclusively used to refer to things that are fabricated/not true. It can also be used in its literal sense to mean the components or what constitutes something else. For example: "the legislative branch of the United States is made up of the House of Representatives and the Senate." In short, a story can be 'made up or made-up' (meaning it is invented and likely not true), one's mind can be 'made up' (meaning one has decided oneself, made a decision), and something can be 'made up of'. Hope this helps. Best, Leo
1
A lot of English words and phrases have different meanings depending of the context. Both "dream of" and "dream about" could relate to something you see when you are sleeping or an ambition or goal. To help in the further explanation I will refer to the two meanings as "sleep dream" and "ambition dream". Luckily sentences usually contain enough hints such as time indicators, frequency, emotions and descriptions. If we are talking about a "sleep dream" then they will likely describe the dream or give enough of a description to give the sentence context. Likewise "sleep dreams" happen once we are asleep and can have a specific time applied while "ambition dreams" are usually present tense e.g. I had a dream last night is a "sleep dream" and I "dream about" is still currently occurring while you are awake, so is an "ambition dream". If somebody come up to me and started a conversation with "I dreamt of being a chef" then I would assume they are talking about an abandoned ambition because it just doesn't make sense that they would be talking about a "sleep dream" with such little details and about such a plain and ordinary dream, so I'd reply with "Why did you give it up". Now maybe my friend was having a joke and he could reply with "I woke up" and we'd both laugh and know that he was talking about a sleep dream. Just use the hints that come in with the context of conversation to determine the appropriate meaning. "I often dream that I am a ferry" is probably talking about a sleep dream since fairies are not real, the tense used is "that" as in present (present tense while in the sleep dream) and it's a recurring event... Now if they said "I dream of being a fairy one day" then I'd assume they are talking about an ambition since they are talking about something in the future that they want to be... I'd think they are weird and tell them that it's not possible but our ambitions don't always need to be realistic, that's what makes them dreams :) I hope this helps.
1
Most people would say "dream about" when talking about literal dreams, and "dream of" when talking about daydreaming or fantasizing. Switching those conventions might lead to lack of clarity. Language is spoken by fallible humans, so "correct form" and "must use" are not very useful nor realistic ways of thinking, in my opinion. "Correct" might be a shorthand for "makes logical sense", or "is used most commonly", or some other practical benefit. But if so then it's not a great term to use, because folks typically won't make that mapping. I would recommend talking about language in terms of "standards" (grammar/spelling/etc), prevalence, and natural-ness. I think those are clearer than "correct" and "must". I can think of three meanings for variants of "make up". The phrasal verb "to make up" meaning "to invent". The noun "make-up" meaning cosmetics. And the noun "makeup" meaning composition. The woman is composed not only of the urge to love; she's made of other things, too.

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today