Grammar issue
can the following sentence be turn into two different passives? And, if not, why?
Original sentence = They reported the incident to the police.
Passive 1 = The incident was reported to the police
Passive 2 = The police was reported the incident
Search from various English teachers...
Answers · 18
3
Passive sentences do not have an "actor"--they do not tell us who did the action. When we make an active sentence passive, the object and subject change places, and you cannot keep one of them in the same place without seriously changing other parts of the sentence.
They reported the incident to the police.
What's the subject of this sentence? They
What's the object? the incident
Who did the action? They
The incident was reported to the police.
What's the subject? the incident
What's the object? we don't have one!
Who did the action? we don't know!
Now, you could say: The police were reported to about the incident. That takes indirect object (to the police; the indirect object is the person or thing a direct object affects) and makes it the subject, but it sounds like a mouthful.
Other options:
The police were informed about the incident.
The police were told about the incident.
2
No
The first is fine but the second is not. A second verb is required.
The incident report was received by the police.
2
No. The first is correct, the second isn't.
As a native speaker - I don't know any formal rules, Grammar was never taught at our schools. All I know is that it is not correct. Reporting as a verb is always used as 'report something to somebody'.
You could use 'a report of the incident was given to the police', or 'the police were notified of the incident'. In fact notified and reported sort-of act as a pair, in terms of that usage.
'police' should also take the plural form.
2
Passive 1 is correct.
Passive 2 is incorrect.
With certain verbs it is semantically implicit that there will be an indirect object (e.g. "give", "award", "offer"; i.e. their meaning suggests that it is very likely there will be an indirect object). With these verbs there is no need to introduce the indirect object with the preposition "to". These can be converted to Passive 2.
Some other verbs can take an indirect object, but it must be introduced by the preposition "to". With these verbs Passive 2 is not possible.
0
yes
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
