Could you please tell me the difference between the following two sentences?
1. Finishing my homework, I went to bed.
2. Having finshed my homework, I went to bed.
Search from various English teachers...
Answers · 6
1
They're very similar. There's a very subtle difference,
The first one means that as you finished your homework, you went to bed. (ie. at the same time).
The second one means that immediately after finishing your homework, you went to bed. It can imply that finishing your homework is what allowed you to go to bed (because for some reason, you didn't go to bed earlier because you hadn't finished your homework).
0
Grossly speaking, the meaning would be the same. There are subtle differences.
When you use the gerund, the '-ing' form it implies that its an action that you're completing in that moment, that has finished. Hence, the first phrase would be impossible because you would only go to bed after finishing your homework... so it really should read, After finishing my homework, I went to bed. Two separate actions, one following when the first is completed.
In the second, it's implied that the action's completed because it uses a perfect form, even though you're using a gerund.
The meanings would be identical
0
Strictly speaking, only the second is correct grammatically. The first means that you finished your homework while you were going to bed. Colloquially, both would be understood to mean the same thing.
0
The first one implies that the speaker went to bed immediately after finishing their homework. Whereas the second one could be anytime after finishing it, hours later, etc.
0
Will be interesting to know too )
I guess second case says more clearly that he was going to bad only after he had his homework finished. While first case doesnt tell it so clear about was it finished or not.
Interesting.
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
