Use of "Could + Perfect Infinitive"
Hey, I need your help, i'm confused. I encountered some problems with "could + Perfect Infinitive". On courses I learned that "could have done smth." means that you were able to do something, but you didn't do it. It's related to past. I know this.
But am I understanding right the next grammar?
"Couldn't/Can't + Perfect Infinitive"
at first, as i understand, for instance in this sentence - He couldn't/can't have done this! - Like I don't believe, i'm definitely sure he didn't do it.
The same with "It can't be!", "She can't be so stupid!", but these one are in the present. I don't believe that may be true. Right?
At second, it also can be used in such situation when, for example "I couldn't have passed final test without your help", it's when I wouldn't have been able to do something if something hadn't happened. But I did it. Kinda conditional sentence. Right?
Two options to use:
1. Certainty that something couldn't have happened.
2. When you look back in the past and say that something wouldn't have been able to happen if there weren't some conditions that helped to make it come true.
And what's the difference in this case between Can't have done and Couldn't have done?
Search from various English teachers...
Answers · 4
1
can't = cannot present
couldn't = could not. past
no difference except the tenses.
"He can't/couldn't have done this!" can have two semantic meanings... one is what you wrote and the other meaning is that he had already done and you couldn't believe it. All depends on the context.
0
I don't believe anyone says "can't have done". The meaning is "couldn't have done". Why not just say "couldn't have done"?
0
couldn't have = wouldn't have been able to
"could" has two meanings:
1. wasn't able (past)
2. would be able (conditional)
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
