Corrections · 8
A Bunch of Tulips for France
We have a new polemic here in France. I don’t know if it's the same in the USA or in the United Kingdom, but we, French people, love controversy and can’t seem to stay many days without a new one. The latest target is the gift the American artist, Jeff Koons, wants to give to France: a gigantic hand holding up a bunch of tulips. It clearly refers to the Statue of Liberty and the artist dedicated it to the memory of the victims of the 2015 terrorist attacks in Paris.
So why is it so controversial? Some people say that the location the artist chose for his work--in front of the Museum of Modern Art of the City of Paris--is not appropriate. Their argument is that it's not on the site of any of the attacks and its installation will upset the harmony of this avenue. It is somewhat hard to take these viewpoints seriously. I'm pretty sure that all memorials are not located exactly on the spot of the event, and the argument of preserving the harmony of anything is as old as modern art itself! Remember, in particular, the uproar of the Louvre Pyramid?
Another argument is not against the work, itself, per se, but rather against the artist. Jeff Koons is "the symbol for an industrial, spectacular and speculative art." However, isn't our very own Eiffel Tower also a symbol of “an industrial, spectacular, and speculative art” also? I won't bother to enumerate the others arguments in order to keep this posting short, but they don't convince me either. Despite what I’ve written, the fact is that usually, I have little to no interest for the works of Jeff Koons. When he exhibited a lobster and a rabbit in the Versailles Castle, I simply didn't see the point. So, I'm somewhat really surprised at myself to stand up for his work here and now, but I'm absolutely not convinced by any of the arguments that I heard or read so far.
Hi Jean. Good job! An excellent use of your views upon a current topic as the subject of your writing! Whatever changes that I’ve made were done to merely allow your sentences to sound more natural to my native ears. I hope that this helps you. J.
A bunch of tulips for France.
We have a new polemic here in France. I wonder if it's the same in the U.SA. or in the United Kingdom, but we, French people, love controversy. We can't go many days without a new one.The subject of the latest is the gift the American artist Jeff Koons, who wants to give France a gigantic hand rising up through a bouqet of tulips.
It refers clearly to the Statue of Liberty, and the artist dedicates it to the memory of the victims of the terrorist attacks in Paris in 2015.
So why a controversy ? Some people say the location the artist chose for his work, in front of the Museum of Modern Art of the City of Paris, is not good : it's not on the spot of any of the attacks and it's going to upset the harmony of this avenue.
Really, I'm not sure all the memorials are exactly on the spot of the event. And the argument of the harmony is as old as the modern art : remember in particular of the Louvre Pyramid.
Another argument is against the artist himself. Jeff Koons is "the symbol for an industrial, spectacular and speculative art.". Isn't our Eiffel Tower a symbol of an industrial and spectaculair art ?
I won't enumarate on others arguments for not to be too long, but they don't convince me either.
The fact is that usually I have no interest in the works of Jeff Koons. When he exhibited a lobster and a rabbit in the Versailles Castle, I didn't see the point. So I'm really surprised to stand up for his work today, but I'm absolutly not convinced by the arguments I have heard and read.
Want to progress faster?
Join this learning community and try out free exercises!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
