Madam C. J. Walker
I just watched the first two episodes of a Netflix minisseries about Madam C. J. Walker. She was a black woman who lived in the US by the end of 19 century and beginning of 20 century. In short, she used to be a poor washerwoman who decided to open her own business. The series shows how she was brave, hardworking, ambicious and persistent in spite of all the discrimination she went trough, both from racism as from sexism.
I don't want to diminish her qualities, in fact I actually admire them, but my point is we have to see this from a critical perspective. When we hear about these stories of resilience and overcoming coming from people who used to be in vulnerable situations, it's easy to get into the idea that that is the solution not only for them but also for everyone else who is in similar places. Something like "oh if he/she would effort more, work harder, they would live better".
But the truth is that is not how you solve social problems. Poverty, hunger, discrimination, and others, are solved by public policies. If the matter is social, then it is the State's responsability to act. The fact that we hear and tell those kind of stories only demonstrate how exceptional they are. It's not like if everybody was hardworking, resiliant, etc they would come out of their vulnerability. I believe that among these people, a lot of them have these qualities, but the thing is they don't have the opportunity to exercise them.
Search from various English teachers...
Corrections · 8
1
Madam C. J. Walker
I just watched the first two episodes of a Netflix minisseries about Madam C. J. Walker. She was a black woman who lived in the US by the end of 19 century and beginning of 20 century. In short, she used to be a poor washerwoman who decided to open her own business. The series shows how she was brave, hardworking, ambitious and persistent in spite of all the discrimination she went through, both from racism and sexism. [More natural would be: ...in spite of all of the discrimination she experienced from racism and sexism. You could also sad: in spite of all the discrimination she experienced as an African-American woman.]
I don't want to diminish her qualities, in fact I actually [the 'actually' isn't really needed there] admire them. but My point is we have to see this from a critical perspective. [Try simply: Yet let's look at this from a critical perspective. or I argue we should look at this story from a critical perspective.] When we hear about these stories of resilience and overcoming coming from people who used to be in vulnerable situations, it's easy to get into the idea that that is the solution not only for them but also for everyone else who is in similar places. Something like "oh if he/she would effort do more, work harder, then they would live better".
0
Madam C. J. Walker
I just watched the first two episodes of a Netflix miniseries about Madam C. J. Walker. She was a Black woman who lived in the U.S. by at the end of the 19th century and through the beginning of the 20th century. In short, she used to be was a poor washerwoman who decided to open her own business. The series shows how she was brave, hardworking, ambitious, and persistent in spite of all the discrimination she went through, both from racism as from and sexism.
I don't want to diminish her qualities -- in fact I actually admire them-- but my point is we have to see need to look at this from a critical perspective. When we hear about these stories of resilience and overcoming obstacles coming from about people who used to be in vulnerable situations, it's easy to get into the idea think that that is the solution not only for them, but also for everyone else who is in similar positions. places. Something like, "Oh if he/she would make more effort, more, work harder, they would live better".
You make some interesting and important points. I have not seen the series, but I know the story. If you have any questions about my corrections, please ask.
0
Madam C. J. Walker
I just watched the first two episodes of a Netflix minisseries about Madam C. J. Walker. She was a black woman who lived in the US by the end of 19 century and beginning of 20 century. In short, she used to be a poor washerwoman who decided to open her own business. The series shows how she was brave, hardworking, ambicious ambitious and persistent in spite of all the discrimination she went trough, both from racism as and from sexism.
I don't want to diminish her qualities, in fact I actually admire them, but my point is we have to see this from a critical perspective. When we hear about these stories of resilience and overcoming coming from people who used to be in vulnerable situations, it's easy to get into the idea that that is the solution not only for them but also for everyone else who is in similar places. Something like "oh if he/she would effort more put more effort in, work harder, that they would live better".
But the truth is that is not how you solve social problems. Poverty, hunger, discrimination, and others, are solved by public policies. If the matter is social, then it is the State's responsability responsibility to act. The fact that we hear and tell those kind of stories only demonstrate how exception exceptional they are. It's not like if everybody was hardworking, resiliant resilient, etc etc. they would come out of their vulnerability vulnerable situation. I believe that among these people, a lot of them have these qualities, but the thing is they don't have the opportunity to exercise them.
0
Great job! I loved this notebook (I also watched the series and liked it). I made corrections generally towards more formal language, as this sounds like an 'opinion' type of essay. Hope that is helpful! Your English is beautiful.
0
This content violates our Community Guidelines.
Want to progress faster?
Join this learning community and try out free exercises!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
