Search from various English teachers...
Hong Kong SAR China flaglynn
how to analyze the structure of this sentence?

 But anecdotal evidence suggests they fall into three broad categories: a few runaway successes, a larger number that come out marginally positive in cost-benefit assessments, and a long tail of failed zones that either never got going, were poorly run, or where investors gladly took tax breaks without producing substantial employment or export earnings.

 

why  "but"can be put in the beginning of the sentence? 

is "where" unnecessary?

"got" and "were" are two verbs together, correct?

Comments · 5

0

I think English learners try to use more correct grammar than native English speakers. We break a lot of rules and aren't always perfect. It is probably because English is so irregular and has too many rules and exceptions. Plus, we don't study our own language as hard as a foreign learner would. Haha :)

0

"either...or..." can be used with more than two items. "I want either apples, bananas, or oranges from the fruit stand."

In this case, "either never got going, were poorly run, or where investors (didn't do their job well)".

Match each of those parts up with the first phrase "a long tail of failed zones that" and you get the meaning. However, for the third one you need to omit "that".

It would be as I said:

"a long tail of failed zones that never got going"
"a long tail of failed zones that were poorly run poorly"
"a long tail of failed zones where investors gladly took tax breaks without producing substantial employment or export earnings"

So..."a long tail of failed zones that never got going or that were run poorly or where investors gladly took tax breaks".

I'm sorry if I didn't answer your question.

0

Thank you for the answers. 

I still don't understand. "either ...or" is a phrase, which means that "never got going, were poorly run" and "where investors gladly took tax breaks without producing substantial employment or export earnings" are parallel. Then I should have two phrases.

 

a long tail of failed zones that never got going, were poorly run,

a long tail of failed zones that where investors gladly took tax breaks without producing substantial employment or export earnings.

 

right?

0

English speakers break grammar rules all the time! You're right! "But" should not start a sentence, but we still do it a lot anyway.

No, that is incorrect. You need "where". Take out the extra information in between and focus on what the last part of the sentence goes with.

"...a long tail of failed zones ... where investors gladly took tax breaks without producing substantial employment or export earnings." CORRECT

You need "where" in order to use the second part to describe the first part.

"...a long tail of failed zones investors gladly took tax breaks...." would be incorrect.

You cannot place those two clauses/phrases directly next to each other ("....failed zones inverstors...." is very incorrect). You need to use "where" to connect them together and use "investors gladly took tax breaks without producing substantial employment or export earnings" to describe "a long tail of failed zones".

I'm not sure what your last question means. If you match each list item up with the first part though (sort of distribute the meaning), you get these three phrases:

"and a long tail of failed zones that never got going"

"and a long tail of failed zones that were poorly run poorly"

"and a long tail of failed zones where investors gladly took tax breaks without producing substantial employment or export earnings"

"Got" is part of "got going" (from "to get going") and "were" is part of "were run poorly" (from "to run poorly).

0

But- technically you're not supposed to start a sentence with "but", but it's pretty common. The "but" here is to contrast what was previously said, implied, or would naturally be assumed. 

Where- no it's not unnecessary. The sentence would be confusing without it.

Got and were- I don't understand your question here. Nothing stands out to me as incorrect where these words were used. 

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today