I think italki rules are just fine. I understand, however, that some people are unable to follow them. Maybe they should look for some other place then?
Some users that were too cheerful for this place in the past left and seem to have fun elsewhere. Go check out one of those places:
evengreener.createaforum.com
and see if you really would like to be a part of something like that? It's a total chaos: people discussing just anything and nobody gets banned? And what next? Free elections? Come on, this is unacceptable.