Tough one.
You use LIKE as a preposition so it is not usually followed by a verb.
You use AS as a conjunction so it is usually followed by a verb.
Your example is correct even though there is no verb. I believe because the verb is implied. The example could be:
Donna came to the party wearing exactly the same clothes as I wore!
The rule is broken a lot by native speakers. Here is a good link:
http://www.grammar.cl/Notes/Like_vs_As.htm