Mike
English
Apr 21, 2020
Bees may be smarter than Wilson. What if bees regard freedom not as a metaphysical belief that explains random motion, but as a normative principle to evaluate alternatives? Determinists have a problem. If any alternative could, in hindsight, be proven determined by other causes, then the theory is useless. Determinism cannot be falsified; but even more important, it cannot guide you among alternatives. Kant calls freedom a "postulate" that requires respect for law, since free beings are causes and causes operate in a law-like way. If bees or anyone can conceive and act on that principle, then it doesn't matter if metaphysical determinism is true. The two standpoints, theoretical and practical, have different purposes, which good Kantian bees appreciate. I suggest that determinism is unfalsifiable because it proves too much. But Kant has a separate reason. In his philosophy, freedom can never show up among the phenomena, and therefore it cannot be proven or used to refute determinism.
