Search from various English teachers...
Profile
Learning
German
Language Skills
EnglishNative
Lesson Feedback
Lesson history
 Last monthLast 3 monthsAll time
Completed lessons000
Attendance rate100%100%100%
Teacher reviews
No record
Activities
  • Posted
    Can anyone help to explain this sentence? Hi to everyone at Italki! I am new to this forum and new to German (I have been learning it for 3 months), and I need some help with a question. I’m teaching myself so have no tutor to ask so it would be great if someone could help. ‘We are giving her a present for her birthday’ Wir geben ihr ein Geschenk für ihren Geburtstag DIRECT OBJECT = ein Geschenk (receiver of action of verb ‘to give’) INDIRECT OBJECT = ‘her’ (to whom object given) I am confused as to what part in the sentence ‘Geburtstag’ is and why, following ‘für’ this doesn’t this take the accusative word for ‘her’ - ‘sie’ rather than the dative word ‘ihr’? I thought that anything following ‘für’ was always accusative and should hence be; ‘Wir geben ihr ein Geschenk für SIE Geburtstag’ Sorry if this is a very basic, easy question, but it’s totally confused me so if anyone could explain it (in VERY simple terms!) I’d be so thankful. Thanks Sally
    September 11, 2013
    6
    0