Present perfect & present perfect progressive
In this sentence:
This is the third time you have been here. What exactly (have you come here for now)?
Why the present perfect is used here but not the present perfect progressive?
Search from various English teachers...
Answers · 5
1
Hello!
The way that I understand it is this: present perfect progressive is used when the action started sometime in the past and is still happening now - so it has been going on continuously which is not the case in this sentence.
In this sentence: "This is the third time you have been here. What exactly have you come here for now?" The present perfect verb is used because this action is happening now - this is the third visit and it is happening now. In the first sentence is it is apparent that the subject has been here before but those actions started in the past and finished in the past.
I hope that helps!
0
Both sentences are correct. However, the emphasis is different in each one.
"What exactly have you come here for now?" The focus is mostly on the now, not on the previous times you've been there. It sounds slightly frustrated but also makes it sound like this may be the last time the person will go there. It is common to use this form when talking about events repeating.
Weronika's sentence is also correct but the emphasis is slightly different. "What exactly have you been coming here for" implies some connection between the previous times you've been there and the current one. It kinda sounds like they expect this person to continue going there.
You can choose which one you want to use depending on your meaning.
0
Weronika H. Wozniak
Thank you so much!
0
Hi Layla.
Thank you for sharing.
If I understood the meaning of the sentence you provided it should probably sound like this:
This is the third time you have been here. What exactly have you been coming here for?
This does use present perfect progressive in the second part of the sentence, which means you’re right.
We use present perfect for experiences and something that has happened many times. In the second half you have to use present perfect progressive because the person mentioned is standing right in front of us right now. We are confronting him/her in present time.
I hope this helps!
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
