Search from various English teachers...
Iraq flagShahla
"The window is broken" I'm a bit perplexed about the passive form of this sentence. It's passive for present time, but the meaning doesn't make sense because the window is already broken(happened)...so why is it in present form?

Answers · 4

1
In this case I believe “broken” is being used as an adjective to describe the situation the window is in now... if you wanna use the passive voice, you should -as you stated use past because That’s when the act of breaking took place.
0
Compare the following descriptions and actions: Descriptions The window is broken. We should replace it. We should replace the broken window. [Broken is a past participle used as an adjective.] The window is dirty. We should clean it. We should clean the dirty window. [Dirty is an adjective.] Actions Joe is breaking the window. The window is being broken [by Joe]. Joe has broken the window. The window has been broken [by Joe]. Joe had broken the window before she came home. The window had been broken [by Joe] before she returned home.
0
Sure, it might be suitable here to actually say, "the window has been broken." But you might want to think of the context. What if someone asked you, "how is the window?"--or, "is the window intact after the storm?"--you might reply by saying, "the window is broken." Sure, again, past form would be best here since it actually matches the series of events of the window being intact, and then no longer being intact. Indeed, no window is broken only in a present time--if you think about how a window breaks. But a speaker's intentions might not be to describe what has happened, rather, they might be using the present tense in order to report the current condition of an object, and not it's past.
0
"broken" is an adjective made of a verb just like The window is small. The window is clean. etc

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today