Like/as
Hi, there
Which of THESE two options is better? Can I use “like” or “as” in this sentence?
“He is losing weight like I lose money”
“He is losing weight as I lose money”
“He is losing as much weight as I lose money”
Thank you
Search from various English teachers...
Answers · 9
1
Hi,
“He is losing weight like I lose money” - sounds very casual, but makes sense.
“He is losing weight as I lose money” - This means "at the same time" but the two are not connected
“He is losing as much weight as I lose money” - This is clear, but a little unnatural.
I would say "He is losing weight as fast as I'm losing money."
I hope this helps!
Michelle
(https://www.italki.com/michelle)
1
Hi! I agree with Monica for the most part, but I personally think the first option is what I would say. "He's losing weight like I lose money" is a joke I might make about a friend who's losing weight, but it requires the assumption that I lose money easily/often.
The third option sounds a little strange to me, as it's not a direct comparison. Like, is he losing weight in currency? How many reais for one kilo, you know? lol
Anyway, I hope that was helpful!
Ide
0
The final sentence is the best option.
The first option is understandable but sounds a little weird to my ears.
The second option sounds like you are talking about two simultaneous actions; while he is losing weight, I am losing money. The point that the two are similar is lost.
Final point, if you are trying to make a point about someone's behavior in general, use "loses" instead of "is losing". "He loses weight like I lose money."
0
please
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
