grammar question
The below sentences are extracts from an article for reading comprehension. I find the original sentence 1 'advocates dislike Houston' and the sentence 2 which is written without *that* unnatural. Are they both grammatically still correct?
1 Many public transportation advocates dislike Houston.
2 They argue *that* the city is too sprawling (it can take more than three hours to drive from one side of the city to the other during rush hour) and that there aren’t enough buses and subways.
3 However, Houston was a source of inspiration for Golden.
Thank you in advance!
Search from various English teachers...
Answers · 8
4
1 Many public transportation advocates dislike Houston.
The word "advocate" describes someone who expresses strong public support for some cause. In your sentence, "advocates" is a plural noun which describes many such people who are in strong supporters of public transportation. A plural noun should be paired with a plural verb "dislike" (without the letter "s" at the end). I don't have the entire context for this sentence, so I will assume that many people who strongly support the use of public transportation feel that Houston does not have a good public transportation system and they dislike living in this city.
2 They argue *that* the city is too sprawling (it can take more than three hours to drive from one side of the city to the other during rush hour) and that there aren’t enough buses and subways.
Sometimes, we can remove "that" and the sentence is still grammatically sound. In your sentence, "that" comes before a noun phrase "the city": "that" is referred to as an object relative pronoun which can be removed without affecting the sentence structure.
Another example: The house that my father sold was fully renovated. <--> The house my father sold was fully renovated. (Both are acceptable.)
However, if "that" is a subject relative pronoun (meaning that the word "that" comes before a verb), we cannot remove it from the sentence.
Example: The house that was sold was fully renovated. (correct) <--> The house was sold was fully renovated. (incorrect)
Sometimes, writers use the word "that" for emphasis.
For example: (A) Susan wanted to show everyone that she was in charge. (B) Susan wanted to show everyone she was in charge. There is more emphasis on Susan's intention by using "that" in (A).
I hope this helps you.
2
All of these sentences are correct. However, as a general rule, you only want to use "that" when you need to. Many teachers and writers don't like unnecessary uses of that. In sentence 2, both of the "that"s can be removed and the sentence still makes perfect sense.
0
Thank you for your kind answer. I am glad you mention this because for me it feels that a spoken and written English should be different and proper writing should not omit words which are natural thing to do in a spoken language. The contracted forms in articles are also unpleasant to me. So I wonder if writing forms are also changing (more American?).
0
- Using 'that' is better in the first part of the sentence because it connects the 'They argue' and the rest of the phrases. It flows much better.
However, the second 'that' which is 'and that there aren't enough buses and subways' should be omitted to make it sounds more natural.
-> They argue that the city is too sprawling (it can take more than three hours to drive from one side of the city to the other during rush hour) and there aren't enough buses and subways.
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
