Search from various English teachers...
Malaysia flagJeannie
Questions about grammar I did some grammar exercises and I've got these questions wrong. Hope that you're willing to clear my doubt about grammar! Thanks in advance! 1. She _____ of running away but she was so scared that her legs simply could not move. a) had thought (my answer) b) was thinking (correct answer) -Why can't I use past perfect in this sentence as there are two actions in it? 2. Up till now, there ____no news about our lost puppy. a) is (correct answer) b)has been (my answer) -Isn't that the word 'up until now' connects the past to present? 3. By the time the bell rang, the children _____ their work. a) had finished (correct answer) b) have finished - 'by the time...' doesn't it mean that the two actions happened at the same time?

Answers · 3

3
Hi Maureen, 1. She _____ of running away but she was so scared that her legs simply could not move. The past perfect tense is often used with the simple past tense to indicate the sequence of two past actions, with the past perfect tense indicating the earlier past action. In sentence 1, all the actions happened simultaneously (e.g. "thought of running away" and "legs could not move" at the same time). On the other hand, she took some time to consider escaping and the past continuous tense describes a past action that took place over a period of time, hence the answer (b). 2. Up till now, there ____no news about our lost puppy. Personally, I would feel that "up till now" means during a period up till the present moment. In the past, there was no news. At the present moment, there is still no news. This meaning is achieved by using the present perfect tense, and your answer (b) is correct. waiting (two hours ago) xxxxxxxxxxxxx waiting (now; our focus on the action stops here) (Up till now, he has been waiting.) Reference URL: https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/up%20till 3. By the time the bell rang, the children _____ their work. Here, there is a sequence of past events. The children finished their work before the bell rang, hence the use of past perfect tense (i.e. had finished) and simple past tense (i.e. rang). xxxxxxxxxx (children had finished their work) xxxxxxxxxxxxxx (the bell rang)xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx(present)xxxxxxxx (future) (more distant past - past perfect tense) (more recent past - simple past tense) "By the time" does not mean that two actions happened at the same time; on the contrary, it signals the end to an action that took place for a duration. Example: By the time the firemen extinguished the fire (end of the act of putting out the fire), many people had died (what happened before the fire was extinguished). I hope this helps.
2
Hi Maureen. Firstly, I'm not an expert in English grammar, but I am a journalist and write all day, so I'll try to explain the answers for you. 1. She 'was thinking' of running away, but she was so scared that her legs simply could not move. To me it's the recency of the event that makes it 'was'. 'Had thought' places something very long ago. For example. 'On Monday I'd thought about making a cake.' Or 'I was thinking about making a cake.' Both effectively past tense, just one is further back. The use of 'but she -was- so scared' is the clue here. If it had said. 'she -had been- so scared' you would have been correct. 2. Up till now, there is no news about our lost puppy. The phrase 'Up till now' places the sentence in the present tense. Up till earlier today, there has been no news about our lost puppy. Earlier today is past tense. 3. By the time the bell rang, the children had finished their work. This can really only be past or future tense. This is past tense whereas 'By the time the bell rings, the children will have finished their work.' is future conditional. I hope that that helps in some way.

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today