Have been in/on??
I've already learned the difference between HAVE BEEN TO & HAVE GONE TO
We use 'HAVE BEEN TO' to talk about life experience. When I use this, I'm saying that I went there but I returned.
Example: "I've been to the US many times before." ( but I returned. I'm not there right now.)
And we use 'HAVE GONE TO' when the person you're talking about is still there.
Example: "Mary is not here. She's gone to work." ( She is still at work)
But I've seen that we can use the preposition IN. In other cases even the preposition ON... Ex.: I've been in...... or On vacation for example.
When do I use IN or ON instead of TO?
Thanks
Search from various English teachers...
Answers · 6
1
Great question.
First, the distinction between "been" and "gone" isn't quite as clear as you think. For absence, only "gone" is OK. However, for life experience, "been" and "gone" are both OK.
"He isn't here now. He's gone to Moscow. He will be back in a week." NOT "He's been to Moscow."
BUT
"I've gone to China 5 times"="I've been to China 5 times." The two sentences mean exactly the same thing.
For "in", "been" is stative.
"Been in (place) for (time)" means "been living in (place) for (time)"
I've been in America for 5 years=I've been living in America for 5 years=I came to America 5 years ago, and I am stll in America now//
"On" can talk about a state or a repeated action.
"He's been on vacation to America for the last week. He will be back on Sunday."
"He's already been on two vacations to America, so next time he wants to go to Norway."
1
Ah, the old "been to" "gone to" thing!
As I have said before, this "rule" is dying. I give for my example, "Have you ever gone to a Stones concert". Nearly everyone returns from a Stones concert. But I do understand the nuance, and WHY "BEEN" IS STRICTLY BETTER; but it is rarely thought about in real conversation. And, for example, changing the tense really complicates things; if you think of, for example, the past tense of the verb to go. "Yesterday, he went to the swimming pool" If go == gone == went, are we to assume that he is still there? Of course not! The whole concept becomes too weighty to handle! And, in this past tense you can hit other problems, like:
He went to the pool vs He was in the pool. Note that the "to" just got changed to "in". You definitely don't say, "He was to the pool."
In everyday speech, if someone asked someone else, "What countries have you visited in Europe?" the other person in England or USA might reply, "Well, I've gone to Italy, France and Belgium." Now, you could say that that was wrong. But the unfortunate thing is that so many people are using this structure that it has to be accepted as common usage, and therefore it has to be accepted as "right", no? In reality no one is interested in whether you came back or not.
So, in summary, I don't think that "gone to/been to" is something to be thinking about too much. Another example could be a mother before leaving in the car with her small daughter. She could say, "Have you gone to the toilet?" instead of "Have you been to the toilet?" - in both cases the little girl returned, because she's not in the toilet now.
With the "in" and the "on" or the "to" you will just have to soak in the general usage. Like:
gone to the pool (went to the pool building most likely)
gone in the pool (went into the water)
been (hah - it's sounds better!!!! in this phrase) across the Millennium bridge
sometimes you don't need a preposition at all - have you been shopping.
Ah, les caprices d'une langue!
0
You know, Lucio, thinking again about the gone to/been to. If you go by the rule that you have learned at least you will be right. The other person (English) will know when to flaunt the rule (and it is slang when they do it, albeit accepted slang). So, I take it back, the rule is useful for you. So keep using it. With in/on/at/through etc. it is impossible to explain all the examples. However one always goes on vacation/holiday (not in). Bom dia.
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
