How can you answer the "...-たことがありますか。" type question?
For example. この映画を見たことがありますか。
1. はい, あります。 (From the book, this is clear.)
2.はい,このえいがをみたことがあります。 (Feels ok, but too long. Maybe good if we want to say that we saw this particular movie.) Edited
3. はい,見たことがあります。
4. はい,見た。
Which is good? Are more good variants too?
Search from various English teachers...
Answers · 7
1
1,3,4 are OK.
but in 4, you should say はい,見ました。 instead of はい,見た。
0
1. はい、あります。 (Good)
2.はい、このえいがをみたことこのえいがをみたことがあります。 (incorrect)
--> はい、この/そのえいがを見たことがあります。
3. はい、見たことがあります。(Good)
4. はい、見た。--> はい、見ました。(in the polite form) / うん、もう見た。(in the informal form)
I would say:
はい、もう見ました。(もう = already)
I hope this helps you.
0
You can just say "あります" or "見た事があります".
I think these are most popular and natural way of reply in Japanese.
"あります" is including the meaning of "はい", and "ないです or ありません" is including the meaning of "いいえ" .
Therefore, We hardly saying "はい" and "いいえ" in daily conversation.
Of course, You can saying "はい" or "いいえ", and It's just fine!!
Personally, I think you might want to use case 4 .
There is any other way to say it, but It depends on the situation or partner.
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
