Search from various English teachers...
Japan flagSatomi_N
Function of "but" Below is an excerpt from a book review on The Witches: Salem, 1692 written by Stacy Schif. I am unsure of my interpretation of "but no one else" at the end of this paragraph. I would like to know how should I understand it. “What sets Salem apart”, Ms Schiff writes, “is not the accusations but the convictions.” She assigns particular blame to William Stoughton, the chief justice at the trials, whose name still adorns a Harvard dormitory. As Ms Schiff points out, he was a bachelor with no knowledge of teenage girls; hence his willingness to allow “spectral evidence” seen by hysterical girls and other accusers, but no one else. If you are uncertain of the purport of this question, please tell me frankly. Then I will do my best to make it clear. Thank you for reading to the end. Perhaps you would explain.

Answers · 3

1
It's the usual meaning of 'but'. The idea is that he allowed this evidence from one group of people, but he didn't allow it from others. You also logically need some conjunction there between the 'girls' phrase 'hysterical girls and other accusers', and the 'no one else'. You could use 'and', but then it's a little less clear.
0
The sentence could also be "to allow 'spectral evidence' seen by hysterical girls and other accusers, but (seen) by no one else." Compare this meaning to "to allow 'spectral evidence' seen by hysterical girls and other accusers, but not to allow any other evidence."

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today