Почему "трепало" а не "трепал" ?
I met that sentence in the book I'm currently reading: К вечеру поднялась гроза. Самолет трепало.
Why "трепало" if самолет is masculine ?
Why not самолету (a dative) if it's an "impersonal" form ?
I don't see the logic, could you shed some ligtht ?
Search from various English teachers...
Answers · 18
5
First of all, it's not passive voice, as it was suggested. Passive sentences contain a subject (in the nominative) that experiences an action. Besides, passive verbs take the suffix -ся. There is no subject in your example, so it's impersonal construction.
In impersonal constructions, you usually use dative case talking about physical/ psychological human states (мне холодно, ему хочется чего-то etc). If the verb is transitive then it can take the direct object in the accusative case, as it does in your example.
1
Update: my answer was wrong.
1
Because 'Самолет трепало' is passive voice, not 'Самолет' 'трепал', but something else '(Оно) трепало самолет'.
Usually the 'Оно' is not spoken or written, and order of words is different, because it is more natural I guess.
1
Hello!
In this sentence subject is missing. This is passive voice, i believe.
Author didn't specify what it was - weather, storm, wind - it. But it made some actions with plane. Thats why 'трепало'.
Самолет - accusative. (Нечто) Трепало что? - самолет.
As example - Машину трясло на плохой дороге.
0
@K P: Thanks a lot for for taking the time to write these explainations, they are really very helpful.
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
