Search from various English teachers...
Switzerland flagVivian
Some questions with tenses (Simple Past/Past Perfect; Present Perfect/Present Perf. Cont.) Why is simple past okay here? I thought past perfect was mandatory, because the second part of the sentence happened before the first? -> "She showed him the letter she had received / received from her brother." Same here: "I knew the poem well because we were studying / had been studying it in our literature class." And here: "I wanted to meet Mr De Jong because he had known / knew my grandfather during the war." (Are they differing in meaning at all?) And why are both tense forms ok here, too? "I have looked / have been looking forward to this concert for ages." Thank you :)

Answers · 5

1
Yes, all of these possibilities are correct. We use them a little bit like adjectives to describe the situation with more details. I will use this example to explain: "I knew the poem well because we were studying / had been studying it in our literature class." - We studied it in our literature class. (This is a very basic meaning with several different possibilities. Maybe they looked at it once. It's possible they reviewed it everyday. It could have been yesterday or two years ago. This one is the simplest description because it doesn't limit the time like the other verb tenses.) - We were studying it in our literature class (This tells me that they studied it over a period of time in the past. It was probably in the recent past or not that long ago. This one is more descriptive. I have the feeling that the class is not finished, and the possibility of studying the poem is still there.) -We had been studying it in our literature class. (This is a specific duration of time in the past. I know it wasn't just once, and I know that they stopped studying. Maybe they stopped because the class is over or maybe the class is finished with this poem. This focuses the attention on the fact that something is over. This limits the situation more than the previous two tenses.)
0
Just because the second action happened before the first doesn't mean that the first tense has to be the present perfect. She showed him the letter she had received = At some point in the distant past, she received a letter. After she received the letter, she showed him it. As we are talking about a specific moment in the past, we use the past simple (showed). This explanation applies to your other sentences. Does that make sense? :)

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today