Search from various English teachers...
Czechia flagRobert
Usage questions Can you answer a “What do you do?” same as you would answer “What are you doing?” and/or “What are you planning to do?” "I was running in a cab." Did I hear that right? "Why she won so easily?" Is this way of asking question possible in speech nowadays? Or is it 99% wrong, or am I not hearing properly? "Rolls was killed instantly - the first British casualty of the new age of flight." I've thought of "to kill" more like of a process than a completed act. Now having doubt, can "killing" be a longer process at all? ‘I’m worth twelve of you, Malfoy,’ he stammered. Malfoy, Crabbe and Goyle howled with laughter, but Ron, still not daring to take his eyes from the game, said, ‘You tell him, Neville.’ What does Ron mean by saying: "You tell him"? "The nisse/tomte is an echo of ancient ancestral cult." Why not "of AN ancient"? Does smirking bear a negative meaning? "A one thing I love about hanging out with you is..." Is it a colloquial intensification? Why not just "One thing"?https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wr_f4dYyIeg&feature=youtu.be&t=25s is the "Why she won" question Thank you for attention!

Answers · 5

2
For the first one: No, you cannot. "What do you do?" and "What are you doing?" are different because, while both are happening in the present, only the second is happening at the moment. The first you answer in the present (I <Run, Sing, Teach, etc.>), the second in the present CONTINUOUS (I am <Fishing, Walking, Talking, etc.>). Second: I don't think so? I've never heard that. There is "Cab running" which is running from a cab so you don't have to pay, but... Third: Almost correct. The tense is wrong, and perhaps the wrong question word. "HOW DID she win so easily". It's hard to explain, but with the five main question words, I've always said win, and not won with he/she/it. Fourth: Not sure what you mean, but if you are asking if you can use to kill as an imperfect verb, then yes. Sort of. Ex: This job IS KILLING me. This is a metaphor, but the killing is in process, and is said in the present continuous. Five: It's kind of like cheering him on. "You've got this." Typical of a verbal exchange, and here it is that Ron's not paying attention, so he says this to please Neville. Six: I believe that's an error. It should be "AN ancient ancestral cult". Seven: In a way, it displays a smug, "I won, and you lost" attitude. It is typically berating. Eight: While intelligible, I've never heard it used in America. It may be a British thing. (Would someone British like to assist?) Well, that's all I've got. hope that helps. I tried to have it make sense, but English is just so weird.
2
"What do you do?" is asking what your profession is. "What are you doing?" is asking what you happen to be doing right then, which could be anything, not just your work. It could be that you are watching TV, for example. So no, you would not answer them the same. "I was running in a cab." does not sound right. They might have said, "I was getting a cab." or "I was hailing a cab." "Why she won so easily?" sounds like bad English. I would say, "Why did she win so easily?" or "How did she win so easily?" If you are killing someone then it is in progress. If someone was killed then it is completed and they are dead. One is in the present and the other is in the past. "You tell him, Neville." Haha, this is a funny one but hard to explain. Malfoy and Neville are in an argument. Neville has said "I'm worth twelve of you, Malfoy." Ron likes that Neville told Malfoy that and is telling Neville to say more things like that to Malfoy. He is being a friend to Neville and supporting him in the argument. I would put an before ancient. It may just be a typo. It does not sound right to me without the "an". Smirking is not always negative, but it usually means someone is trying to hide their smile but they can't stop from smiling a little bit. Usually they want to hide it because they are laughing at someone who does not want to be laughed at. "A one thing" is wrong. It should be "The one thing" or just "One thing". If you say "The one thing I love about..." it means that is the one and only thing you love about it. If you say "One thing I love about..." it means that this is one of many things you love about it.

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today