【English Grammar】What is the difference between "Did you see my watch" and "Have you seen my watch"
For example, if you can't find your watch, then you ask your mum "Mum, Did you see my watch this morning?" or "Mum, Have you seen my watch?"
It seems that both of them are correct with grammar. But I am really curious about the difference between these two sentences, especially in meaning this aspect. And which one is more common?
Thank you guys so much~~~
Search from various English teachers...
Answers · 13
5
Hello,
In the situation you give 'Have you seen my watch' is the most common and natural question to ask. You don't say when the action took place but there is a result in the present (Hopefully your mum can tell you where your watch is!)
Once you fix the action in finished time then you would use the other option - Did you see my watch last night? I can't find it anywhere.
Please note this answer is for British English, you may get a different reply from an American
Best wishes
Bob
4
I would just like to add that as an American, we would use it the same way. The present perfect form "Have you seen...?" would be more common unless, as Bob said, there was a specific time attached.
0
A little bit more information (to suppliment to Bob and Lincoln):
Sometimes you'd find that it almost makes no differnce in meaning to use the simple past tense or the present perfect, where the former is commonly used in the us and the latter in the uk.
0
thank u^^
0
Yes to add to the above answers.
Did you....
to remember when to use this, think of what you refer to as something that already happened
Did you watch the England game last night.
As the England game was before the time of the present conversation
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
