I don't understand this sentence in the book.
I read the sentence below, but I don't understand it.
"But a woman who walks alone in the wilderness for eleven hundred miles?"
My confusion are:
1. It ends with a question mark, so what does this sentence ask for?
2. In spite of the question mark, this sentence does not have a question sentence structure.
Is there someone analysis this sentence for me? Thanks in advance.This is the whole paragraph which including this sentence:
"But a woman who walks alone in the wilderness for eleven hundred miles? I’d never been anything like that before. I had nothing to lose by giving it a whirl."
Search from various English teachers...
Answers · 8
2
It's a rhetorical question - "a question asked in order to create a dramatic effect or to make a point rather than to get an answer." She states before this, "I'd been so many things already..." a mother...a daughter...a granddaughter...but a woman who walks so much? the answer is obviously 'no, never'
You could use this figure of speech yourself. For instance, I've eaten many crazy things in my life; chocolate covered ants, raw horse meat, living squid, but fried bull testicles? I'm not sure I have the balls ;)
Hope that helps!
0
Thanks Ava Gessner. It seems that the author has a little doubt about what she would be when she walked on the long distance trail. She tried to define the role of herself in such lifetime. So, this sentence is not a real question sentence, it is a statement. Did I get it?
0
The paragraph preceding this one seems necessary in order to understand. For example, if it said something like "I've always been an odd person. But a woman who walks alone in the wilderness for eleven hundred miles? I’d never been anything like that before. I had nothing to lose by giving it a whirl." The sentence seems like it shouldn't be a question because it's split up.
0
The whole paragraph is below:
"But a woman who walks alone in the wilderness for eleven hundred miles? I’d never been anything like that before. I had nothing to lose by giving it a whirl."
0
This sounds like a sentence from a novel or short story. Are you able to provide the one or two preceding sentences (the sentences before this one)?
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
