Search from various English teachers...
North Macedonia flagRena Fly
But when all I see WERE/WAS Carly's trees? When all you see WERE Carly's trees... When all you see WAS Carly's trees, you stop thinking about.... Was or were? Is 'all you see' singular?

Answers · 7

2
It sounds wrong to be singular. "All" is a plural noun so use: "All you see were".
2
To expand on Alan's answer The simple answer is it is 'are'. When all you see ARE Carly's trees, you stop thinking about.... If you specifically need a past tense variant you can also use When all you SAW WERE Carly's trees... Though this requires you to change 'you stop thinking about' to 'you stopped thinking about' to make the tenses agree. A more detailed explanation is as follows; A better way to look at the grammar is to rearrange the clause. You stop thinking about .... when .... is also a way to say this, so (When) Carly's trees ARE all you SEE. (Makes grammatical sense) (When) Carly's trees IS all you SEE. (Grammatically incorrect as 'Carly's trees' are plural and 'is' is singular) (When) Carly's trees WERE all you SEE. (Doesn't make grammatical sense as tenses are present and past) (When) Carly's trees WERE all you SAW. (Makes grammatical sense) (When) Carly's trees WAS all you SEE. (Doesn't make grammatical sense, past and present tenses are mixed again, and singular and plural forms mixed too) Then you can place the correct form back into your example by reversing the order. In this form you can see that the form of the verb is actually determined by 'Carly's trees' not by 'all you see' because 'Carly's trees' are the focus and the 'all you see' of this clause. So three points are important. 1. Make sure your tenses agree. (In this case you cannot have 'see' present tense, and 'were/was' past tense in the same clause.) 2. Try to rearrange sentences/clauses to see if the grammar makes sense/to identify the verb modifier. 3. 'All' is a singular or plural indefinite pronoun depending on what it is referring to.
1
It seems that you need the present tense here. You can rephrase the sentence to eliminate the difficulty: "When Carly's trees are all you see, you stop thinking about..."
0
I think the phrase "all you see " takes singular form. Because the fact or reality what you all see is only one truth.

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today