Search from various English teachers...
Japan flagrioko
Why do you put "FOR" in this sentence? FOR who could learn to love a beast? Thank you for taking a look at this question:) I know that it means "No one ever learns to love a beast." I guess that this "for" has a role of emphasizing the meaning of "who". What I want to know is why you put "for." I think this "who" is subject. So as usual, I think you don't have to put "for." There must be a reasonable reason for using "FOR," instead of using at, in, on, or something like that. But I'm completely at a loss about why. Why do you put "for" in these sentences?I get to know this expression in a song of Augustus Gloop, which is used in a movie Charlie and the Chocolate Factory. This greedy brute, this louse's ear, Is loved by people everywhere! For who could hate or bear a grudge Against a luscious bit of fudge?

Answers · 13

2
That's a bit of a weird one since it's somewhat poetic and wouldn't crop up much in normal speech. It sort of implies a futility, as if it's something impossible: "For who can hold back the sands of time?" "For who can turn back the clock?" "For who can forgive the unforgivable?" "For who" is sort of used to imply that "nobody can". You could substitute "nobody" in place of "for who" and the sentance would keep it's meaning. You could also substitute the phrase "after all" and it would likewise keep it's meaning: "After all, who coukd learn to love a beast?" Pretty much has the same meaning. It's a hard one to describe since you won't really hear it outside of novels/quotes, it really isn't used much.
2
When you ask about "using "FOR," instead of using at, in, on, or something like that", it seems you are thinking of the word as a preposition, whereas here, it is acting more as a conjunction. Perhaps it becomes clearer if you substitute the near synonym "because". The remaining issue is that there seems to be nothing for the conjunction to conjoin! One might expect some clause like "He was despised ..." or whatever to precede the "for". But in this case, either it has been separated into another sentence (which we are not shown) for effect, or it may just be implied.
1
examples of uses for for me to go along with this. for whom. for you. for me. if it where not for her, I would be nothing. I gave you the gift, it was meant for you, so you should keep it. I went to look for him, but did not find him.
1
It depends on the context of the sentence. There was something said before that sentence that required "For".... it means something like "because" Another example: "All people should be vegetarians, for who should eat an animal?"
1
A simple answer is that this use of the word " for" is basically a poetic word . Most normal people would not write the sentence this way, its sort of like using fancy poetic English. If that makes any sense to you I hope. Basically, the sentence is complete without a change in meaning by not even using the word " For " . " Who could hate or bear a grudge Against a luscious bit of fudge?

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today