Search from various English teachers...
Hong Kong SAR China flagMatthew
What is different between "Did " and "Have" when asking somebody a question? For example, Have you bought the cellphone for your father already/yet ? Did u the cellphone for your father ?

Answers · 5

3
Simply, just know that WHENEVER you use did, the verb that comes after that becomes present even though you are still asking about the past. Notice the verb in this example : "Did you DO (present tense) your homework?" Here's the question when using Have : "Have you DONE ( past tense) your homework?" Hope this helps! Feel free to ask me if you have any more questions! Diana.
2
There's really no difference in practical usage. Americans tend to use both, while the British prefer "have." However, when forming the perfect tense it is always better to use "have" because it shows a time period that began sometime in the past, continues until right now, and may continue until some time in the future. Whereas "did" is really only used for the simple past. So there is a big difference between "Have you met James?" and "Did you meet James?" The first question asks if someone has been introduced to James, and the second questions asks if the two people "met" (which could be their first meeting or their 10th!).
0
lol I tried explain this but I gave up! Thanks to Brad for explaining. Did is firmly in the past Note you can say "did you buy" but not "did you bought" but you can say "have you bought", you certainly can't say "have you buy". It's odd that I know the correct format from familiarity of usage but when I try and explain why, I struggle. (I guess I should have said "try to explain" there, indeed I am not sure if I actually say "try an explain".) So now I realise I don't understand my own language!!

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today