Search from various English teachers...
China flagSanya
Do you think the sentence is correct? STANDING as it does at the top of the hill, the temple is well preserved. The predicate verb of 'as' clause should be 'stand' according to the meaning. If 'standing' takes the -ing form, 'does' must be misprinted, which should be 'is'. Do you think my correction makes sense? Thank you?Compare the following three sentence: Standing as it does at the top of the hil,the temple is well preserved. Stand as it does at the top of the hill, the temple is well preserved. Though it stands at the top of the hill, the temple is well preserved. Do you think is there any differences among them?

Answers · 6

1
The second one is incorrect (wellll?...see the end), so let's just get that one out of the way. Your thinking on the first one has an understandable logic to it, but unfortunately, the internal logic of the English sentence is different from yours. :) What are the basic premises? A) The temple stands at the top of the hill. B) The temple is well-preserved. if you throw an auxiliary into A, you get: "the temple does stand on the top of the hill." Now, "standing" has nothing to do with the present progressive here; it's a participle modifying “temple". Take out "as it does" for the moment: Standing on the top of the hill, the temple is well-preserved. We like *that*, right? Back to A with the auxiliary: it does stand. -- Do you eat stinky tofu? Yes, I do. ("eat it" dropped) Does the temple stand? Yes, it does. ("stand" dropped). So, Standing as it does (stand) on the top of the hill... To your other question, are there differences? Yes. Standing as it does at the top of the hill, the temple is well preserved. It stands on the top of a hill AND (therefore?) it's well-preserved. Though it stands at the top of the hill, the temple is well preserved. It stands on the top of a hill BUT it's well-preserved (anyway). As I've been writing this, I've thought of other "well, *maybe* in this case" examples that perhaps muddy the waters rather than clarify, but I think I'll quit while I'm ahead. :)
0
#1 and #3 are fine. #2 is wrong. It doesn't form the same relationship between the two clauses.

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today