Search from various English teachers...
Italy flagMarianna
Must or Have to? How can I understand when to use "must" and when "have to"? If I always use "have to" is an error?

Answers · 3

4
In general, "must" and "have to" mean about the same. But there are a few differences to remember. 1 "Must" is stronger and more formal so is more common in rules, signs, laws, etc. For example, in every restaurant in America there will be a sign in the bathroom that says, "Employees must wash hands before returning to work." 2 The meaning and use of "must" and "have to" are very different in the negative form. (Sorry if you already know this.) must not = do not do this! (Passengers must not use cell phones during the flight.) don't have to = it is not required / it is optional (He doesn't have to work on Saturday.) 3 The meaning / use is also different in the past. The past form of "must" is "must have" but this does NOT mean obligation. In the past, you should only use "had to," not "must have" to talk about rules or obligations or things you have to do. 4 "Must" is also used for deduction. (He has an Italian passport, so he must be from Italy; her house lights are off so she must not be at home.) People sometimes also use "have to" in this way (Options A, B, and C are wrong, so the correct answer has to be D). But it is less common. And remember that "must not" = I am 100% certain it isn't but "don't have to" = I am not 100% certain it is ... two different meanings!
3
These modal verbs - 'must' and 'have to' - are very similar, but there is a small difference. 'Must' is usually used to express a personal obligation (i.e. the speaker has decided that something is necessary), whereas 'have to' suggests that somebody (or something) else has imposed the decision. For example: 'I must study English' (my personal intention), or 'I have to study English' (a teacher or a circumstance makes me do it).
1
Marianna - there is a website that gives guidance - have a look at it: http://www.englishgrammarsecrets.com/musthaveto/menu.php Auguri John

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today