False passive
Hi again!
I am hoping that someone may be able to explain the premise behind ‘the false passive’ in German as I am finding it very difficult to understand.
I would write the sentences;
1. The house is destroyed
2. The house was destroyed
in German as follows;
1. Das Hause wird zerstört (present passive)
2. Das Haus wurde zerstört. (imperfect passive)
However, the information that I have read on the passive says that these translations are incorrect, describing them as ‘false passives’ and that they should be correctly written as;
1. Das Haus ist zerstört
2. Das Hause war zerstört
but unfortunately doesn’t give a proper explanation as to why this is the case.
This seems to be totally contrary to what I have learned in forming the passive and am now totally confused.
I have incidentally, from a different source, found an almost identical sentence;
‘The window was opened’
Translated as;
‘Das Fenster wurde aufgemacht’
which obviously uses the passive.
Obviously I am missing something here, perhaps very easy and obvious, but which unfortunately I cannot understand and hope that someone may be kind enough to explain it to me!
Thanks
Laura
Search from various English teachers...
Answers · 2
3
There are two kinds of passive in German, the "Vorgangspassiv" describing an action (using "werden"), and the "Resultatspassiv" describing an result (using "sein").
Das Haus wird/wurde zerstört: Vorgangspassiv, it's about the action.
Das Haus ist/war zerstört: Resultatsperfekt, what matters is the result.
I think calling one of them 'false passive' may be a bit confusing.
It's the same for your other example:
Das Fenster wurde aufgemacht/geöffnet: Vorgangsperfekt, emphasis on the fact that someone opened it (but of course now it's open).
Das Fenster ist aufgemacht/geöffnet: Resultatsperfekt, emphasis on the result, namely that it's open now.
The tense is not important, except that (as in the above example) the result of a past Vorgangsperfekt can also of course be observed in the present.
1
Hi,
The house is destroyed. => Das Haus ist zerstört. (static passive / present)
The house is being destroyed. => Das Haus wird zerstört. (dynamic passive / present)
The house was destroyed. => Das Haus wurde zerstört. (dynamic passive / past)
The window was opened. => Das Fenster wurde geöffnet. (dynamic passive / past)
The window is open. => Das Fenster ist offen. (static passive / present)
I hope this explains the difference.
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
