A question asked by student
hello, I was asked a question: why " the first six to cross the river will win." can't be written in this way: " the first six crossing the river will win." To me, both make sense, but the first sentence, according to the answer, is correct. Can anyone tell me how to explain both? Thank you.
Search from various English teachers...
Answers · 9
0
Darryl Wee had a good answer.
You could also make this clear by saying "the first six to finish crossing the river will win."
0
First of all, we should note the the phrase “to cross the river” is functioning as an adjective, qualifying (actually, identifying / restricting) our reference to “the first six.” Personally, I would use the infinitive phrase, since it implies a degree of doubt and unreality — we don’t yet know who the first six will be. Therefore, I would indeed say "the first six to cross the river will win."
On the other hand, while not my preference, it would not be a mistake to say "the first six (racers) who cross the river will win." The relative clause “who cross the river” serves the same purpose as the infinitive in the first example. Finally, we could indeed reduce the relative clause, giving us "the first six (racers) crossing the river will win." Note that in English grammar, the word “crossing” in is an active participle in this context, not a gerund.
0
Hi Wen,
This is a common question: when to use the gerund "-ing" versus when to use the infinitive "to (verb)." In this case, because the action is incomplete, we have to use the infinitive "to cross." If the action was in progress or already completed, we'd use the gerund "crossing."
I hope I've helped answer your question. Please let me know if I haven't.
0
The goal is "to cross the river", not "crossing" the river.
The first example is clearer in its goals. "To cross" defines the task as "to reach the other side of the river", and the first person who does that will win.
In the second example, "crossing" means that the crossing action is ongoing. It also suggests that whoever is struggling in the middle of a river will win (and does not have to reach the other side of the river).
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
