Search from various English teachers...
Spain flagAntonio
Problems with basics: "What time is it?"? As far as I can remember from my lessons when I was a beginner, english questions usually have this syntax: 1ºquestion word (when needed) 2ºauxiliary verb 3ºsubject I did some research and now I refreshed some parts and noticed some exceptions to this rule for the verb to be with the present and past simple. But even that I can't understand why is the question "what time is it?" so odd (to me I mean) and different. What does "time" in the middle of it wrecking havoc? This may be a baby question, but I feel that if I still continue with this lack on basis I won't ever be able to speak correctly.

Answers · 18

2
I'm not sure about the idea of drawing an analogy with "what color is it?". If someone says "what color is it?" then a reasonable response is "what color is *what*?" in order to determine what object is meant by "it". On the other hand, if someone says "what time is it?" then a reasonable response is NOT "what time is *what*?". Consequently, "it" is not a true pronoun, it's possibly a dummy pronoun or a redundant pronoun since the expression can only mean "what time is the time", and if you're going to say that then you might as well fix it to "what is the value of the time variable?". To me, "what time is it?" and "is it raining?" and "was it cold yesterday?" can be though of as malformed or, to be charitable, at least irregular. Expressions like that, and their answers, sound like they haven't been thought through properly. Consequently my advice would just be to think of them as irregular special cases and just memorize them. An interesting exercise, though, is to puzzle out how they could be made logical. Let's take "was it cold yesterday" as an example. What is "it"? Must be the temperature. But temperatures are measured on numeric scales, not on subjective and meaningless axes such as "hot" and "cold". A scientist couldn't function if that were the case. A temperature can be expressed as a figure on a given scale, or temperatures can be compared with =, >, <, and so on, therefore one temperature can be higher or lower than another. Therefore if you ask "was the temperature relatively low yesterday?" then you're moving a bit closer to asking a logical, actionable, question. Just my two cents. :)
2
the "time" is there just like any other similar word would be such as "What size is it?" "What color is it?" etc
2
Just think of 'What time' as the question word.
1
'Time' comes with 'what' in this case. It means that 'what' acts as an adjective here (we the Italians consider it a sort of 'special adjective', while English speakers call it a 'determiner', but the substance of the thing is the same), since it's joined to the noun 'time'. This is a similar sentence: 'What colour is it?' When 'what' is used as a pronoun instead, you have a sentence like this: 'What is it?' As you can see, here 'what' is used alone, without a 'noun', because it's a 'pronoun', it substitutes a 'noun'. '
0
Antonio, I see that you still think that 'what time is it' doesn't follow the normal rules of making questions, I invite you to read again my first comment here, where you will find that it's a sentence which perfectly follows those rules (question word + verb + subject). As you can see, nihil sub sole novum! (Sorry, I can't help writing in Latin today). As to Santa's question above, I'm not sure of my answer, certainly a native speaker (I'm not) can help.

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today