Problem with infinitive sentences
Hey guys. I'm learning english and I'm having some difficulty with verb + ing for infinitive sentences.
When I say, for example, to sleep early is very boring, is it wrong? I must to say: sleeping early is very boring?
(Another example: After to see you, I felt much better and After seeing you, I felt much better).
What is the rule to know that?
Thank you.
Search from various English teachers...
Answers · 7
1
I would say that there is a rule on which to use, albeit not perfect. The general rule is this:
1. when the idea is about something that will happen in the future, or about necessity, a potential or expectation, or one's wish or preference, use the infinitive.
2. if it is about what already happened, something recurring routinely in the past or present, use the gerund. Also, gerund is the only possible choice for an object of a preposition.
For example:
(infinitive)
- want to, wish to, prefer to, love to, hate to: wish, liking, preference.
- intend to, expect to, mean to, in order to, so as to, "to be or not to be": future, intention, potential.
- remember to, forget to: future, a unique thing one has yet to do.
(gerund)
- keep -ing, repeat -ing: something recurring.
- enjoy -ing, love -ing, hate -ing, miss -ing : habits and practices.
- after -ing, on -ing, since -ing, because of -ing, on account of -ing: object of preposition.
(some words can use either, with some nuance difference - I exaggerate the distinction a bit below)
- I hate losing a friend: I hate it when I lose a friend.
- I hate to lose a friend: I dread the possibility of losing a friend (for this occasion).
- I remembered calling her: I remembered the fact that I called her in the past.
- I remembered to call her: I remembered that I must call her.
- I stopped smoking: I stopped the practice of smoking repeatedly (quit smoking).
- I stopped to smoke: I stopped what I was doing to have a smoke.
There may be exceptions and certain cases where such distinction is blurred, but I believe the above rule can easily cover more than 50 percent of all cases.
Your example:
1. "Sleeping early is very boring." - general practice, so gerund is preferred (it is not talking about this evening).
2. "After seeing you, I felt much better." - object of a preposition, so gerund.
1
Great questions, Andre, and ones I've answered many times!
Your first example:
We do not say "sleep early" in English. We say "go to bed early."
You can use either the "TO-infinitive" or the "VERB-ing" as the subject in English sentences. Both are correct: Going to bed early is boring! To go to bed early is boring! (However, in modern American spoken English, we use the "VERB-ing" as subjects much more. People will think you are Shakespeare himself if you say "To go to bed early..."!! :-)
Your second example:
The rule is: "After + VERB-ing"
Unfortunately, there is no easy way to remember the rules for infinitives and gerunds. You just have to memorize each one. To know for sure, use: The Oxford Advanced Learner's Dictionary. (It's a website and an app - besides being an old-fashioned book which I have next to me on desk right now as I type (even though I'm a native English speaker, sometimes I get confused!)
Wishing you success!
0
Thank you Ileana =)
0
Hey, Andre! Here are some brief issues concerning your doubts:
First, a gerund is a verb in its -ing form that functions as a noun that names an activity rather than a person or thing. Any action verb can be made into a gerund. So they can appear at the beginning of a sentence when used as a subject, ex: Jogging is a hobby of mine* or act as an object following the verb, ex: Daniel quit smoking a year ago.*
Both gerunds and infinitives can be used as the subject or the complement of a sentence. However, as subjects or complements, gerunds usually sound more like normal, spoken English, whereas infinitives sound more abstract. Gerunds sound more natural and would be more common in everyday English. Infinitives emphasize the possibility or potential for something and sound more philosophical. If this sounds confusing, just remember that 90% of the time, you will use a gerund as the subject or complement of a sentence.
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
