Some questions about the gramma of English
I've seen 2 sentences which bothered me when watching "Friends"
1: Chandler is going to have a promotion to be a manager, but he refused, and to explain the reason he said"I know, but if I took it" . I was wondering why "took" should be used here instead of "take"??
2: Someone in the series said"Who are you going out with? ". Shouldn't it be"Whom"??
Search from various English teachers...
Answers · 6
2
1. 'If I took it,...' is part of a second conditional sentence, for example, 'If I took the job, I'd have to work 16 hours a day.' We use second conditionals for hypothetical situations which are either impossible or unlikely.
'If I take it,..' is part of a first conditional sentence, for example, 'If I take the job, I'll have to work 16 hours a day.' We use first conditionals for situations which are likely to happen.
The speaker's choice of a second conditional tells us that he probably doesn't intend to take the job.
2. No, definitely not. 'Whom' is only used in formal, mainly written contexts. It would be inappropriate to use 'Whom' in informal conversation of this type.
1
1) If I took it, I would make less money
2) If I take it, I will make less money
1 means that you've already decided not to take it.
2 means you're still thinking through the decision.
And yes, grammatically, "With whom are you going out?" is the correct form, but colloquially we move the preposition "with" to the back and say "who" instead of "whom" even though it's incorrect.
"With whom are you going out" -> "Who are you going out with"
"With whom are you meeting with, tonight" -> "Who are you meeting with, tonight"
0
1: Chandler is going to have a promotion to be a manager, but he refused, and to explain the reason he said"I know, but if I took it" . I was wondering why "took" should be used here instead of "take"??
The reason why Chandler is using the past tense of "to take" is because the option of taking the job or not happened in the past and therefore when he is talking about the job he is looking back to the past and thus using the past verb tense.
2: Someone in the series said"Who are you going out with? ". Shouldn't it be"Whom"??
You are totally right; if we were speaking strictly in terms of correct grammar, that someone should use whom instead of who. However, colloquially, in everyday conversations, people tend to not make that different and use who.
You can remember when to use "who/whom" by substituting "he/him" in the sentence. You wouldn't say "I'm doing the project with he," you would say "I'm doing the project with him." So it's obvious that whom is the pronoun you would use here, not who. If you can answer the question with he, then you'd use who.
Hope this helps!
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
