Why is the second sentence wrong?
1:He is from Australia, as you can tell from his accent.
2:He is from Australia, which you can tell from him his accent.
I saw a question that say the second one is wrong and the first is right.
I know the first one is better but I cannot clearly explain why. I was asked about this and in trouble.
Thank you.Sorry, the second sentence doesn't have "him", it's a typo.Thank you all, I still have a question though.
I think "which" sometimes refer to the sentence before, like, "It rained all day yesterday, which I expected." Why can't I use "which" like that here. The meaning of the sentence might be like, so I thought ,"He is from AU, and you can tell the fact that he is an Australian from his accent."
Search from various English teachers...
Answers · 7
2
First of all, you submitted this question to the wrong place. Second of all, the second sentence, even though it's technically wrong.... but if it's just speaking then I think it's okay. However, when it comes to "exercises", it can be a little bit annoying.
まず、貴方は間違っているところに質問を出しましたよ。
では、質問について、第二文は確かに少し間違っているんですけど、話なら、大丈夫だろかもしれませんね。でも、テストなら、ちょっとめんどくさいね。
REMINDER: Don't be so focused on solving multiple choices questions or exercises if you want to "speak" a language. Otherwise, you're just going to "learn" the language.
注意:外言語を喋ることができたければ、謎とか、テストとか集中しすぎてだめですよ。
Back to main issue here.
話題に戻ります。
So I'm going to give you an example: ”2.1 He is from AU which is a beautiful country.”
それでは、私は例文があります、よく見てください:”2.1 He is from AU which is a beautiful country.”
Now, I'll make this sentence a non-relative clause: "He is from AU. It is a beautiful country.
So as you can, that "which" replaces the ". It" right? So the question is.....if you were to make a non-relative clause version of your 2nd sentence, what would it be?? I have no answer....because there is nothing for the "which" to replace to begin with. That's why it's wrong.
では、あの文章は”Non-relative clause"にすると、”He is from AU. It is a beautiful country.”になります。確かに”. It"を”which"に替えるのが見えるのでしょう。それから、私からは、ひとつの質問があります。それは:”もし貴方の第二文はnon-relative clause版にすれば、なん文になりますか。私は答えなんてできません。そういうわけでは、第二文が間違っていると思います。
So why is the first sentence correct? Well, the "as" is used there to kind of show the reason as to why the speaker says "He is from AU" at first.
第一文について、あの”As"は最初は”He is from Au"って言うわけを表すために使うと思います。
2
Remove the word "him" from the second sentence and it is correct as well. The emphasis is slightly different in the two sentences ("which" brings information about the first part of the sentence), but they are both correct.
1
1:He is from Australia, as you can tell from his accent.
2:He is from Australia, which you can tell from his accent.
I think both sentences are technically fine, however, the first sentence is better. "Which" is a relative pronoun, so it will refer to the preceding object, and in this case, Australia serves as the direct object. "You can tell Australia from his accent" is not a great sentence. Therefore,I would say either the first sentence or this one "He is from Australia, and you can tell this from his accent." Hope this helps. Good luck!
1
It's very clear because of him and his we cannot use both of them
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
