The imitation game-2014
Will someone be so kind as to explain the meaning of this quote
"You think that because you are sitting where you are and I am sitting where I am that you are in control of what is about to happen."
Search from various English teachers...
Answers · 4
3
Isn't it to do with relative positions of authority? Is this something that Turing says to the man in charge of the project?
If so, it means "You think that because you are sitting in the boss's chair that you are in control of what is about to happen."
2
There are layers of meaning.
The macro context of the movie is that Turing shortened, if not helped win, the war and saved many lives. He was eventually persecuted for his sexual preference, force-fed hormones as a "cure", and as a result killed himself. This was how government bureaucrats, or civilisation, showed their gratitude. It is pitifully ironic.
At the workaday level, this genius and the most sensitive of souls was supervised and bullied by ignorant, ruthless and philistine bureaucrats, even while he was trying to crack the German code. This is where the dialogue you quoted took place.
It is the contrast, and battle, between arrogant unfeeling bureaucracy and the sensitive talented individual. Those are the two chairs.
Therein lies the tragic irony.
You quoted well. It is an angry, though helpless, cry of a sensitive and oppressed genius.
1
It's from the opening of a very good movie, "The Imitation Game," a dramatization of the pioneering computer scientist Alan Turing.
Turing is being questioned by a government agent. If I recall correctly, the agent is behind a desk or table, and Turing is sitting in a plain chair? In any case, the place where someone is "sitting" can be figurative language for their position within a power structure.
In many (all?) cultures, the kind of chair a person sits in is one of many signals of power or social rank. This makes its way into many English expressions. The king's ornate chair is called a "throne," and "throne" can also be used to mean the king himself. People speak of "the seats of power." The head of a department at a university might be called "the physics chair." The person who directs a meaning is "the chairman" even if he is standing up behind a lectern.
Anyway, Turing is saying "You are a government agent with the power to send me to jail, and I am only a university professor. You think that because of where you 'sit,' your official power puts you in control of this situation. You are wrong: I am in control, because of what I know."
It's an arrogant statement, because Turing is in serious danger, and it tells us right at the beginning of the film that Turing is an arrogant person.
1
The first person ['you'] is sitting in a position of authority, and the second person [ ' I ' ] is challenging that by asserting that 'you' are not in control of the situation.
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
