Search from various English teachers...
Brazil flagAlanna Mara
present tense not for past I read that present perfect tense can use to say something in past, but my teacher say some cases cant? When Present perfect tense cannot use for situation happening in the past?

Answers · 3

0
The Present Perfect Tense can be "perfectly" used to indicate past. That possibility usually occurs if the time/date/occasion is not mentioned. Here we have a clear example of Present Perfect indicating a past conversantion. "I HAVE talked to James and could tell he is completely recovered from the terrible flu he had" As opposed to the following PAST Tense sentence in which TIME is mentioned. "I TALKED to James LAST NIGHT" As a rule of thumb, Present Perfect Tense CANNOT be used for the past when you wish to mention WHEN the situation happened.
0
The present perfect is often used to indicate something that started in the past but is still true. Example: "I have lived in Rio for six years." In this case, you started living in Rio six years ago, you still live in Rio, and you may live in Rio for many more years to come. So this is not strictly "the past"--it's also the present and (maybe) the future. The same is true with verbs like "work," "play" and "study" ("He's played tennis for 14 years" also means he still plays it today and, probably, tomorrow). Likewise, if I say, "I've been here for two hours," it means I was here two hours ago; I was here one hour ago; and I am also here right now! Again, the past and the present can be contained within this tense.
0
Basically, present perfect is using a past event to describe the present. That is, the past action has a connection to, or is relevant to, the present. A completed action in the past that has no connection to the present uses past simple (you'd also indicate when in the past this happened). Past perfect is used for a past event which comes before another past event. Properly speaking, the past perfect event should have some connection to the later past event.

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today