Search from various English teachers...
China flagJack Hong
Is it correct here to use 'ka' instead of 'ga'? (JP) I saw a sample sentence on my JP textbook saying 壁に何かあぃますか。 Can we use a 'か' here rather than a 'が'?

Answers · 5

1
There's a typo in your question. Do you mean: 壁に何かありますか?= Is there something on the wall? 何か = something Actually, it could be: 壁に何か'(が)ありますか? The が is usually left out here.
0
壁に何かありますか。=Is there anything on the wall? (Asking if there is something.) 壁に何がありますか。=What is there on the wall? (You already know there is something on the wall.)
0
'か' 1.用於疑問句 eg:どうしましたか?(疑問詞+か) 2.助詞(不肯定的時候) eg:誰か部屋にいます。(好像覺得有誰在房間,但不肯定是不是,只是感覺上覺得好像有人在) 'が 1.助詞(肯定的時候) eg:誰が部屋にいます。(覺得有人在房間,但不知是誰人) 2.接續(有轉接,對比的意思) eg:東京は賑やかですが、九州は静かです。
0
"壁に何がありますか?" is totally correct. But I still see the difference. Meaning, "What is the object on the wall?" It would be used when you have already know there is something on the wall, but you couldn't identify what it is. Namely, I can say that 「何か」 is used for "Is there-?" question while 「何が」 is for "what is-?" question.

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today