'Dari yang ............'
1) Dari apa yang dia bilang, aku tahu mereka pintar
2) Dari yang dia bilang, aku tahu mereka pintar
3) Dari yang apa dia bilang, aku tahu mereka pintar
From what he said, I knew that they were clever!!
Is there any difference in the meaning of the above 3 sentences.
Is one better than the other or is there another way to say this sentence better?
Search from various English teachers...
Corrections · 9
1
This is better that the other:
1) Dari apa yang dia bilang, aku tahu mereka pintar
Or you can said like this :
1) Dari apa yang dia katakan, saya mengetahui bahwa mereka pintar .
0
'Dari yang ............'
1) Dari apa yang dia bilang/katakan, aku tahu mereka pintar
2) Dari yang dia bilang/katakan, aku tahu mereka pintar
3) Dari yang apa dia bilang/katakan, aku
tahu mereka pintar
From what he said, I knew that they were clever!! Is there any difference in the meaning of the above 3 sentences. Is one better than the other or is there another way to say this sentence better?
It's better to say "Aku mengerti apa yang dia bilang/katakan kalau mereka pintar" (I understand what he said that he is clever)
0
'Dari yang ............'
1) Dari apa yang dia bilang, aku tahu mereka pintar2) Dari yang dia bilang, aku tahu mereka pintar
3) Dari yang apa dia bilang, aku tahu mereka pintar
From what he said, I knew that they were clever!!
Is there any difference in the meaning of the above 3 sentences.
Is one better than the other or is there another way to say this sentence better?
--------
Honestly, the 3 sentences are acceptable. But for me personally, no.1 & 2 are more natural than no.3.
Above the three there weren't any diffence in meaning. (i highlighted the words that has meaning both english and bahasa) All the same.
0
hii
0
1) Dari apa yang dia bilang, aku tahu mereka pintar
This is correct.
When the speaker says this, the "apa" is omitted which is normally done.
3) Dari yang apa dia bilang, aku tahu mereka pintar
Incorrect.
Want to progress faster?
Join this learning community and try out free exercises!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
