Search from various English teachers...
United States flagDawson Darling
German Grammar used Correctly? Dative Personal Pronouns Attempting to learn the Dative personal pronouns but first I have to make sure I'm actually working with sentences that actually are Dative and grammatically correct. Can you confirm for me? (1st Person) mir: Sie gab es mir. (She gave it to me.) (2nd Person) dir: Ich würde dir alles geben. (I would give it all to you.) (3rd Person m/n) ihm: Das Essen schmeckt ihm. (The food was tasty to him.) (3rd Person F) ihr: Ich folgte ihren Anweisungen. (I followed her orders.) Er rannte zu ihr (He ran to her) (1st Person pl) uns: Sein schien gut zu uns. (He seemed fine to us.) (2nd Person pl) euch “Ich möchte euch allen gegenüber fair sein.” (I want to be fair to you all.) (3rd Person pl) ihnen: “Der Präsident war gemein zu ihnen” (The President was mean to them.)

Corrections · 4

0

German Grammar used Correctly? Dative Personal Pronouns

Attempting to learn the Dative personal pronouns but first I have to make sure I'm actually working with sentences that actually are Dative and grammatically correct.

--> you can find out if a pronoun is a Dative pronoun by asking this question "Wem". Example: She gave it to me: Sie gab es mir. Wem gab sie es? Mir. So you know that "mir" is the Dative pronoun of the sentence. 

Can you confirm for me?

(1st Person) mir: Sie gab es mir. (She gave it to me.)

(2nd Person) dir: Ich würde dir alles geben. (I would give it all to you.)

(3rd Person m/n) ihm: Das Essen schmeckt ihm. (The food was tasty to him.)

(3rd Person F) ihr: Ich folgte ihren Anweisungen. (I followed her orders.) Er rannte zu ihr (He ran to her)

(1st Person pl) uns: Sein schien gut zu uns. (He seemed fine to us.) Here there is a mistake. If you ask the question "Wem", you ask: Zu wem schien er gut. Uns. So uns is your Dative pronoun. --> to who did he seem fine? To us. In order to have "he" as an answer, you would ask a different question. You'd ask "who seemed fine to us". He. When you ask the question with "who" (aka "Wer"), your answer defines your Nominative pronoun. The nominative pronoun in this case is "Er". Wer schien gut zu uns? Er. In this answer you don't say "Sein". So your correct sentence would be "Er schien gut zu uns". 

Also: the correct translation of "He seemed fine to us" would be "Es erschien uns als ginge es ihm gut". But the sentence is more complex. So stick to this one. Just know that "Er schien gut zu uns" means "He appeared good to us", which doesn't make a lot of sense. 

(2nd Person pl) euch “Ich möchte euch allen gegenüber fair sein.” (I want to be fair to you all.)

(3rd Person pl) ihnen: “Der Präsident war gemein zu ihnen” (The President was mean to them.)

The rest is correct. I hope the explanation is clear...it's hard for me to correctly explain it. 


Want to progress faster?

Join this learning community and try out free exercises!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today