Corrections · 1
Should animals have human rights?
I saw an interesting talk on TED recently about the legal status of apes. The question was whether apes (or animals in general) should have human rights. Should they? I had to ponder for a while about that.
Although I wouldn't call myself an animal lover I oppose all kinds of animal cruelty. In my view it is irresponsible to conduct trials on animals just to develop a new perfume or shampoo. Or to kill animals just to get their fur, trunks or whatever animal products people consider precious.
But is this reason enough to "promote" animals to legal personhood? I mean, let's take an ape who is held in a small and dirty cage because it is part of a trial to find a cure for, let's say, cancer. Some people would argue that the trial itself is not OK because no animal should suffer just because humans want to have a better life. I can relate to this, but if the majority of humans agree to conduct those trials, shouldn't we at least make these trials as "comfortable" as possible for these apes? I mean put them in big and clean cages, feed them with their favorite bananas and let them suffer as little as possible.
Your answer is probably yes, but in the case shown on TED I heard about two chimpanzees who were treated more like things you use and throw away but than beings with feelings. Some animal rights activists wanted to find a way to force the people conducting the tests to treat them better and therefore they wanted to give them the legal status of a person who can sue for their rights.
If this is the only way to prevent unnecessary torture of animals, fine with me. {Also, fancier, "Should this be the only way..."} But for me it would be much better if we could convince our own species that profits should never prevail over the feelings of another species, regardless of their legal status. {Alternatively, "whether they're legally 'human' or not"}
Want to progress faster?
Join this learning community and try out free exercises!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
