Search from various English teachers...
Venezuela flagPaul GarridoProfessional Teacher
Why Esperanto has not become the language of the world Esperanto is a linguistic experiment created a long time ago with the purpose of allowing people all over the world to communicate with each other. However this artificial language doesn`t have a cultural background that supports it and that encorages us to learn it. Language is to culture as history is to geography: there`s always something else to learn besides the subject as a whole, we`ll need references to understand the origins of an issue and more information to get a current situation or its future. On the other hand, English today plays that roll being the most spoken language in the world and the communication vehicle between let`s say a chinese and a sweedish in Yemen. Languages are not meant to be alone and English has proven to have a very extended cultural background, in addition to the best music of the world and the greatest films ever made. Esperanto will keep being just an experiment as long as a whole group of its speakers decides to found their own country and creates something that the rest of the world can remember them for. (Part my opinion, part looking for an extended text) ;)

Corrections · 5

0
http://www.mezzoguild.com/esperanto/
0
Thank you Hilary for all the information. If ever need Esperanto or get to know personally anyone who does, I`ll let you know first, count on it!
0
Neither English nor Esperanto have become “the language of the world”. Neither language is universal but both are international. I see Esperanto as a remarkable success story. It has survived wars and revolutions and economic crises and continues to attract people to learn and speak it. Esperanto works. I’ve used it in about seventeen countries over recent years. I recommend it to anyone, as a way of making friendly local contacts in other countries. I am no less British when I speak Esperanto, of course. Each speaker of Esperanto brings with him / her ideas and traditions from his native tongue, but that mother tongue remains intact. I’m concerned by your claim that Esperanto “doesn`t have a cultural background”. You might be surprised to learn that Esperanto has an extensive indigenous culture and an original literature to rival that of many ethnic tongues. Naturally it didn't start out that way, but when you have such a large community speaking a common language for such a long time, it's probably inevitable that a culture will emerge. People around the world use Esperanto every day for everything from childrearing to religious worship to technical manuals to travel guides. Finally, you describe Esperanto as an “experiment”. If it is an experiment, is a very long and successful one. In 128 years, it has managed to grow from a drawing-board project with just one speaker in one country to a complete and living natural language with around 2,000,000 speakers in over 120 countries and a rich literature and cosmopolitan culture, with little or no official backing and even bouts of persecution.
0
I agree completely. Language, culture and history are closely intertwined. To establish Esperanto as a common global language would require something to happen that is so profound that it changes the course of human civilization.
0

Why Esperanto has not become the language of the world

Esperanto is a linguistic experiment created a long time ago with the purpose of allowing people all over the world to communicate with each other. However this artificial language doesn`t have a cultural background that supports it and that encorages us to learn it.
Language is to culture as history is to geography: there`s always something else to learn besides the subject as a whole. We`ll need references to understand the origins of an issue and more information to understand the current situation or predict its future.
On the other hand, English today plays that role being the most spoken language in the world and the communication vehicle between - let`s say - a Chinese person and a Swede in Yemen. Languages are not meant to be spoken alone and English has proven to have a very rich cultural background, in addition to the best music of the world and the greatest films ever made. Esperanto will keep being just an experiment as long as a whole group of its speakers decides to establish their own country and creates something for which that the rest of the world can remember them for.

(Part my opinion, part looking for an extended text) ;)

Want to progress faster?

Join this learning community and try out free exercises!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today