Russian subjunctive
There's is an opinion that russian language has one type of the subjunctive only forming via the particle 'by' [бы].
E.g. "я сделал бы это, если бы он пришёл". This phrase comprises two condition types:
а) Present subjunctive. Real condition with possibility to change something. English equivalent is 'I would do it if he came'
б) Past subjunctive. Unreal condition without any opportunity to change anything. Expressing regret. English equivalent: I would have done it if he had come.
In russian language these subjunctive types coincide.
It turns out to be not really true. There's grammatical ability to tell one subjunctive type from another.
For example:
а) Present subjunctive. "Надо бы ему прийти, тогда я сделаю это" [He should come then I will do it]
б) Past subjunctive. "Надо было ему прийти, тогда я сделал бы это" [I wish he had come I would have done it then]
It proves to be the combinations `надо было`, `можно было` unambiguously relates the clause to the past subjunctive.
Moreover the present subjuntive uses the particle 'бы' and the past subjuntive uses the verb 'было'.
This becomes more interesting if we take into account that the particle 'бы' is the ancient form of the past tense (aorist) and now loses its verbal character.
In checz language we can still see its verbal nature.
Search from various English teachers...
Corrections · 1
0
Hi Michel ! A very interesting point that you submit here. Мне интересно узнать об этих нюансах. Au fait, comment ça va? Cordialement. JP
Want to progress faster?
Join this learning community and try out free exercises!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
