Corrections · 2
A V-ing question.
I saw a sentence in my textbook. "Jerry always turns off his computer when he is not using it."Why it is not "Jerry always turns off his computer when he doesn't use it."?
In my experience, the regular thing should use simple tense to describe. Why it use "using" here? Any difference between the two sentences ?
Hi Ana,
The first sentence is in the present progressive to indicate something happening now or soon, not as a generalization or repetition (Jerry is not using the computer now…). Furthermore, the verb “is” is a stative verb, which is expressing a state rather than an action, in contrast to the verb “does,” which describes actions. In other words, one describes the condition of the subject, but the other describes the action he is taking, which are completely different ideas.
There is no difference within the “meaning” behind each sentence, however, no native speaker would write or say the second sentence IMHO. Trust the examples in your textbook, and learn these differences between “is” and “do.” That information is there for a reason…
I hope that this helps you. J.
Want to progress faster?
Join this learning community and try out free exercises!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
