Corrections · 14
Such developments mutations, ("mutations" has a clear, literal meaning, and in the context of genetics and DNA editing to use it symbolically would be peverse) as the article says, could be entirely beneficial. But ("the thing is that" - this does not really add anything to your meaning and might be better left out) this is not so clearcut to the majority of the scientists. They (or, perhaps better, "We" ) don’t have enough knowledge about the consequences that such operations might have on the future generations (nor on the indidual experimental subjects - who will become people - themselves).
The scientist himself said that what he did could serve to eliminate this particular disease from Africa. The Guardian calls that claim a fantasy. It doesn’t have to be eliminated by such means, but by using other, lower cost methods. The problem in Africa isn’t a lack of science, but the life conditions of the people. So the scientist doesn’t seem to be driven by compassion, but by hubris and an (probably nicer with an "an" here) ambition of playing (or "to play") God. No wonder his behaviour was condemned by some of his more important ("senior" ? " most celebrated"? Do we really think that some of his colleagues are "not important", in ethical discussions? Or that only scientists have an input on ethical debates surrounding their work ...?) colleagues.
Our desire to use the science to improve the world created by unaided (I'm not sure you can use "unaided" here - it's not wrong grammatically, but it sounds strange) nature without human assistance (is this what you mean?) and to be able to control the evolution isn’t a bad thing. But we need to be responsible for our actions, and to take into account the consequences they might bring.
The Guardian’s view. *
Therefore in the Guardian’s opinion (*"in the Guardian writer's opinion" - can an abstract object or an organisation like a newspaper really have an opinion?) this experiment was absolutely unnecessary, pointless and unethical.
The fact of being able to modify human DNA in order to prevent possible illnesses such as AIDS or genetic syndromes is one of the greatest victories of science over nature.
The Guardian’s view.
Yesterday I read an article in "The Guardian" about a Chinese scientist who used a powerful gene-editing technology to modify the gene responsible for transmitting HIV. It might have sounded completely ok and even astonishing if the experiment* wasn’t performed, partially and patchily, on two perfectly healthy embryos. Their father carries the virus, but not their mother. Theoretically they can’t contract the virus through the father so the babies were at no more risk of catching the virus than anyone else.Therefore, in the Guardian’s opinion, this experiment was absolutely unnecessary, pointless and unethical.
Modifying human DNA to prevent illnesses such as AIDS or genetic syndromes is one of the greatest victories of science over nature. Such mutations, as the article says, could be entirely beneficial. But this is not so clearcut to the majority of the scientists. They don’t know enough about the consequences such operations will have on future generations.
The scientist himself said that what he did could help eliminate this particular disease from Africa. The Guardian calls it a fantasy. It doesn’t has to be eliminated by such means, and other cheaper means can do. The problem in Africa isn’t lack of science, but living conditions. So the scientist doesn’t seem driven by compassion but by hubris and playing at God. No wonder his behaviour was condemned by some of his important colleagues.
Our desire to use science to improve the world created by unaided nature and to** control evolution isn’t a bad thing. But we need to be responsible for our actions and take into account the possible consequences.
*I think you mean that the baby embryo genes were modified ("the experiment")?
**"be able to control..", "be able to walk..", etc, don't normally add much to "to control", "to walk", etc, although you will see these extras in academic or Guardian circles.
Very well written!
Want to progress faster?
Join this learning community and try out free exercises!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
