I've been wanting a cat / I have wanted a cat
So, I was doing my "English Grammar In Use Supplementary Exercises" and I saw these two phrases:
I have wanted a cat.
I've been wanting a cat.
The task was to choose the correct one. I chose "I have wanted a cat".
I was quite surprised to see that the book marks the both phrases as correct.
I thought "want" is a non-continuous verb: https://www.englishpage.com/verbpage/types.html
Could anyone explain why we can use "have been wanting" in this case?
Search from various English teachers...
Corrections · 8
0
I see. I didn't actually know that we can use "wanting" like this, it sounds very unusual for me.
0
"I am wanting a cat" is perfectly good English, but I don't think it means what you think: "I want a cat". It means you are missing a cat; ie a cat should rightfully be with you but is not.
0
No, my problem is with "want".
We can't say "I am wanting a cat", can we? We also can't say "I am knowing it".But "I have been knowing it for many years" is ok(?). So, some verbs can't be use in Continuous, but can be used in Perfect Continuous?
Of course, there is MacDonalds with their "I'm loving it", but that's on purpose. I think that in real life people use "I like/love", not "I liking / loving" it.
0
On second thought, I think it is not "want" which is the verb that is causing you trouble. As usual, it is the verb "to be." You can say "I've been" doing/having/wanting/working/walking...continuously...right?
0
"I have wanted a cat" sounds like you used to want one but don't anymore - it sounds weird to me so I am surprised it is correct. "I've been wanting a cat" is fine and sounds better to me, I would think you started wanting a cat some time ago and you still want one.
Want to progress faster?
Join this learning community and try out free exercises!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
