Search from various English teachers...
Spain flagAlé
Grammar doubt about verbs Which one is correct, and why? I'm eating some biscuits while I'm listening to you, I have eaten some biscuits while I have listened to you. I have been eating some biscuits while I have been listening to you. Thanks in advance.

Corrections · 4

1

Grammar doubt about verbs

Which one is correct, and why? It depends on the circumstance. I will explain more.

I'm eating some biscuits while I'm listening to you,  This is the two events happening now, at the same time.

I have eaten some biscuits while I have listened to you.- Awkwardly phrased. "I have" make this sentence the past tense, but we would be more likely to say "I ate some biscuits while I listened to you"

I have been eating some biscuits while I have been listening to you. This is present tense but it is awkwardly phrased. "I have" here means something that began in the recent past but continued until now. eg "I have been studying a lot of English" or "I have been playing football" 

I hope this helped! 

Thanks in advance. 

0
Finn's explanation is pretty spot-on. Just like in Spanish, I have eaten implies you started something but not necessarily finished, I have eaten half of my breakfast (but will continue to finish the rest), I have applied for a loan (but haven't been notified as to if it was accepted or declined). I had eaten means you are no longer doing it, possibly due to an interruption or simply the action ended, I had eaten half my breakfast before you called me, or I was eating my breakfast when you called me. I have been eating also implies more of a long-term state such as I have been eating biscuits every day while listening to you, meaning every day so far you have been listening to the same person speaking while you eat your breakfast. Since you are doing them at the same time right now, the correct way would be to say I'm eating some biscuits while listening to you. Estoy comiendo una galletas mientras que te estoy escuchando He comido unas galletas mientras que te he escuchado He estado comiendo (se lo usa en el español latino, ¿también en el castellano?) una galletas mientras que te he estado escuchando.
0
I am doing the 2 actions right now, at the same time.
0
Well, it depends. Are you currently doing this action right now, or did this happen in the past?

Want to progress faster?

Join this learning community and try out free exercises!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today